The Global Housing Market Is Entering Its Most Unpredictable Phase in Decades

Outside a modest semi-detached house on a soggy afternoon in North London, a slightly crooked “For Sale” sign is displayed. The uneven growth of the grass underneath it indicates that it hasn’t been trimmed in weeks. The windows only show gray sky, and the curtains are still drawn inside. The length of time it has been silently promoting a house that no one appears interested in purchasing, at least not yet, is difficult to ignore.

These kinds of scenes are becoming oddly common.

Once characterized by steady booms and busts, the global housing market now seems uncertain, almost hesitant. Affordability has changed significantly as a result of rising mortgage rates following years of low borrowing costs. Formerly eager buyers are now taking a step back and recalculating monthly payments that appear significantly higher than they had anticipated. The confidence that formerly characterized the market seems to have diminished.

It was a completely different mood just a few years ago. Open houses in places like Sydney and Toronto felt crowded and competitive. At the door, people took off their shoes and hurried from room to room while whispering to agents to determine how much more than the asking price they were prepared to pay.

Several of those same rooms are now empty.

Subtle but significant behavioral changes have resulted from higher interest rates. Homeowners who obtained mortgages at historically low rates appear hesitant to sell because they might never again be able to afford such low-cost financing. It feels safer to remain where you are. It seems reasonable to wait.

However, something unusual is being created by this waiting.

Not because demand is high, but rather because supply is sluggish, inventory is still low. The high cost of borrowing makes buyers hesitant. Due to the perceived financial risk of moving, sellers are hesitant. As a result, the market seems to be frozen, despite the fact that underlying pressures are still increasing.

It’s possible that this impasse will go on longer than anticipated.

Four

An additional layer of uncertainty is being added by demographics.

Nowadays, a significant portion of the market is made up of older homeowners in many nations. Younger buyers might otherwise buy properties from these owners, who frequently stay in their homes longer. As populations age, some analysts predict that this will eventually change and more homes will be available for purchase. The change won’t occur fast enough to matter, according to others.

It’s still unclear if this so-called supply wave will come gradually or all at once.

Entire apartment buildings appeared strangely silent at night, their windows dark, when I recently walked through parts of New York. Investors probably held onto some of the unoccupied units, waiting for the ideal time to rent or sell. Previously aggressive purchasers, investors now seem cautious, closely monitoring interest rates and calculating risks that didn’t seem important before.

That prudence is novel.

Housing markets are based on belief, more so than most financial systems. When consumers anticipate price increases, they take swift action. Hesitancy increases with uncertainty. For now, it appears that hesitation is winning. Additionally, a more profound psychological change is taking place.

Almost everyone believed that purchasing a home was a secure financial move for many years. Especially for younger buyers who are dealing with high prices and unstable economic conditions, that assumption feels less certain now. Instead, some are rejecting the idea completely, renting for longer periods of time, delaying ownership, or opting for flexibility. It seems like the cultural definition of homeownership itself may be subtly shifting as we watch this develop.

In contrast to previous housing crises, this one does not have a single tipping point. Banks seem more careful. Lending requirements have not changed. Rather than collapsing, the market appears to be undergoing a gradual, uneven, and occasionally imperceptible adjustment.

This makes future predictions exceptionally challenging.

Some markets are still expanding due to supply constraints or population growth. Others are becoming weaker and are slipping more slowly than they are crashing. Buyers and sellers find it more difficult to decide when—or whether—to take action as a result of these contradictory signals.

Investors appear to think that opportunities will present themselves at some point. Simply put, they don’t know when. Right now, the global housing market is stuck in an awkward middle ground. not booming. Not going down. Holding out.